Discover what sets Byler's pickle varieties apart, from Old-Fashioned Dill Pickles and sweet Icicle Pickles to peppery favorites and tangy Mustard Pickle Chips, with simple ways to bring each flavor to your table.
Pickles are a staple of what we make here at Byler Canning Co., and everyone seems to have a favorite. Some like the garlic and tang of an Old-Fashioned Dill, while others reach for something sweet, spicy, or flavored with mustard. A few on the side can finish off a lunch, and some chopped into a salad or spread can give a familiar recipe a different taste. This guide takes a look at our pickle varieties, how they compare, and easy ways to enjoy them at your own table.
Garlic, dill, and a good vinegar tang define our Old-Fashioned Dill Pickles. There's no added sugar to soften that savory flavor, making them a natural choice for anyone who prefers their pickles tart rather than sweet. Finely chopped into homemade tartar sauce, they give mild fish a lively companion; added to deviled eggs, they bring a welcome bite to the smooth filling.
For those who reach for the pepper, Old-Fashioned Fire Dill Pickles add red pepper to that same garlicky dill flavor. You get the tartness of the original with heat alongside it, still without added sugar. Try a few chopped over a baked potato with sour cream, or serve them with a plate of barbecue when you'd rather add spice at the table than season the whole meal.
A little cane sugar takes our Sweet Dill Pickles in a different direction from the old-fashioned variety. The garlic and dill are still there, but the vinegar has a softer edge, giving you sweetness alongside the savory seasoning. Try them layered into a turkey sandwich, where they add flavor to the mild meat, or finely chopped into a dressing for shredded cabbage. They give a homemade slaw a sweet dill flavor without losing the tartness that makes it refreshing.
Sweet Fire Dill Pickles are for the days when you want sweetness and pepper in the same mouthful. Their dill and garlic seasoning sits alongside the sugar and vinegar, with red pepper adding heat to the mix. Spoon some chopped pickles over a sausage in a bun, or scatter them over the bowl of rice and shredded pork. You get a sweet, spicy topping that seasons each forkful without needing another sauce.
Our Bread & Butter Pickles get their familiar flavor from the balance of cane sugar, vinegar, and spices. The sweetness mellows the tartness, while turmeric gives them their golden color. They're the kind of pickle you can pass around at the picnic or set beside a homemade sandwich, with a sweet, gently seasoned taste that feels right at home.
A few pieces in a homemade burger sauce bring that onion seasoned flavor into the spread. They also make a good topping for a breaded chicken sandwich, where the vinegar tang cuts through the coating and the sweetness complements the mild chicken. For a simpler lunch, pile a few onto buttered bread with a slice of cheddar.
Spicy Bread & Buter Pickles keep the onion and sweet vinegar flavor but add pepper heat. Try them with meatloaf, where they offer a sweet-spicy alternative to a little extra ketchup, or chop them into a topping for hot dogs. They're an easy way to give familiar comfort foods some warmth while keeping the bread and butter taste you enjoy.
Sweet pickled lovers will find something familiar in our Icicle Pickles. Cane sugar and pickling spice give them an old-fashioned flavor, with enough vinegar tang to keep the sweetness in balance. A five-day natural fermentation is part of their preparation, and their seasoning takes a different path from our dill varieties: not so much garlic and dill focus, just the character of a traditional sweet pickle.
For a simple way to enjoy that flavor, mince a few into ham salad. Their sweetness complements the salty ham, while the pieces of cucumber give the spread some texture. Or set out a small dish with a supper of roasted meat and potatoes, letting everyone help themselves. They don't need to be mixed into a recipe to earn a place at the table.
If mustard is a regular at your table, our Mustard Pickle Chips will feel right at home. Ground mustard gives them an earthy, slightly sharp flavor, rounded out by cane sugar and vinegar. Turmeric adds their golden color, making these chips easy to spot among the jars. The mustard is what sets them apart: more savory depth than a plain sweet pickle, with a character that suits hearty, simple meals.
Serve a few with leftover roast beef or a thick slice of ham, letting the pickle do the work you might usually ask of a spoonful of mustard. In potato salad, they bring both the pickle and mustard flavors together, with pieces of cucumber breaking up the soft potatoes. They also make a welcome addition to a ploughman's style lunch of bread, sharp cheddar, and cold meat.
A small dish of pickles can feel as much a part of supper as the bread basket. Pickling began as a way to preserve a harvest, but the flavor gave people a reason to keep the tradition going. Cucumbers became something worth enjoying in their own right, with seasonings and sweetness that could vary from one recipe to the next.
Part of their lasting appeal is what they add to a meal. A tart pickle gives your palate a change from rich meat or a buttery side, while its firm texture offers something different alongside softer foods. Sweet varieties bring another kind of contrast, and pepper or mustard adds its own character. A few pieces can change the way a plate tastes without changing the recipe itself.
There's also something practical about passing pickles around the table. Everyone can choose the flavor and amount they enjoy, leaving the main dish just as it is. That makes them easy to share at a family supper or gathering where one person likes things sweet and another reaches for something spicy.
At Byler Canning Co., our different varieties make room for those preferences while keeping pickles a familiar part of everyday eating. You might have a favorite jar that always come out at lunch or enjoy setting out a couple of kinds for company. Either way, the tradition carries on in a simple act: opening a jar and sharing something good with the people at your table.
QA: Which Byler's pickles have no added sugar? Old-Fashioned Dill and Old-Fashioned Fire Dill have no added sugar in their listed ingredients. The Sweet Dill, Bread & Butter, Icicle, and Mustard pickles include cane sugar. Always check the jar’s nutrition and ingredient information for your individual dietary needs.
QA: What can I do with leftover pickle juice? A small splash can add flavor so salad dressing, coleslaw, or a sandwich spread. Dill brings a savory tang, while sweet pickle brine adds sweetness too. Add it gradually before adjusting the salt or vinegar. Do not use leftover brine to make a new shelf stable canned pickles.
QA: Can you add pickles to hot food? Yes. Pickles work in grilled sandwiches or as a topping for baked potatoes, rice bowls, and other warm dishes. Add them near serving time when you want to keep their texture distinct. Heating them longer will soften them, which may suit a filling or sauce.
QA: Which pickles go best on a burger? Old-Fashioned adds a savory tang, Bread & Butter adds sweetness, and Mustard Pickle Chips bring mustard flavor along with the pickle. For heat, try Old-Fashioned Fire Dill or Sweet Fire Dill. Choose according to the other toppings and how sweet or spicy you like your burger.
QA: Which pickles should I use for homemade tartar sauce? Old-Fashioned Dill Pickles give tartar sauce a savory, garlicky tang without adding sweetness. If you prefer a sweeter sauce, try Sweet Dill or Bread & Butter Pickles instead. Finely chop them so the flavor mixes evenly into the sauce.
QA: Can I use chopped pickles instead of relish? Yes. Finely chopped pickles make a useful substitute when you're out of relish. Bread & Butter or Icicle Pickles suit recipes calling for sweet relish, while Old-Fashioned Dill works for dill relish. The texture may be chunkier, so chop them to suit your recipe.